Bolstering the bluffs: Del Mar stabilization project seeks to save coastal rail


By Paul Sisson
North County Times
September 11, 2007

DEL MAR -- Though it costs $3.7 million, the Del Mar bluff stabilization project will not look like anything when it's finished.

Walking along the bluffs Friday, Ramon Ruelas, a senior transportation engineer for the San Diego Association of Governments, explained that the project is designed to keep ocean waves from washing away the bluffs and sending the coastal rail line into the Pacific.

"The point is to protect the track and keep it operational," Ruelas said.

Since May, a construction crew has drilled 136 holes into a section of the Del Mar bluffs, reaching depths of between 40 and 60 feet.

Those holes are now filled with steel I-beams and colored concrete, and workers are adding horizontal underground tie-back braces which reach east under the nearby coastal railroad tracks. Unlike the sea walls used in other cities, the entire system will be concealed underground.

Though waves washing against the bluffs may some day expose the concrete pillars, they will be invisible for years, if not decades.

Over the years, bluff failures have gradually pushed the edge of the precipice ever closer to the tracks where about 60 commuter and freight trains rumble by every day. Years ago, the North County Transit District installed an electronic slip-detection system on the bluffs to provide advanced warning of a sudden collapse, theoretically allowing conductors to stop their trains if the rails were ever blocked or missing.

Ruelas said that instability in the bluffs, including a recent collapse in Del Mar, has convinced everyone that it is important to bolster the tracks in addition to provide warning to trains.

"We believe it poses an immediate problem at this time. Otherwise we wouldn't be out here," he said.

In 2002, a 39-year-old man was found dead, buried in a small cliff cave about 30 feet up the bluff face at Carlsbad State Beach. On Jan. 15, 2000, a sunbathing Encinitas woman died after a bluff failure just north of Moonlight Beach. And in 1995, a bluff collapse at Torrey Pines State Reserve just south of Del Mar killed two people and injured a third.

Engineer Christopher Poli of Santa Ana-based Bureau Veritas Group, a firm hired by the association of governments to assist with the project, said Friday that the beach-going public should not get a false sense of confidence from the stabilization project. The new piles, he said, only protect land to the east.

"The bluffs will continue to collapse for the part that is closest to the beach," Poli said. "There is still nothing holding that back."

While a sea wall similar to those employed by coastal home owners might seem to provide more protection to the public, Poli said a wall would not have provided enough support for the train tracks.

"There are also a lot of concerns about how sea walls look," Poli said.

This summer ocean-view home owners in one of San Diego County's most exclusive locales have been awakened by the construction work, which has been performed at night. The project has had to be done nocturnally, Ruelas said, because the work requires workers to stand on the rails while they drill holes, and there are too many trains using those rails during the day.

"We've had to do everything between 10 (p.m.) and 5 (a.m.)," he said.

Construction noise is one thing. But drilling in the middle of the night is something else.

Del Mar resident Walter Baldwin, whose home on 12th Street is very close to the work, said Friday that while he personally has only been awakened twice by construction noise, many of his neighbors have had a tough time getting a good night's sleep since drilling began in May.

"It has been very bad on some evenings for some families. But, in general, I think most people have accepted the reality that the last thing they want is to have a cliff go down," Baldwin said.

While he said he sympathizes with home owners' sensitivity to the noise, Ruelas said it could have been worse.

"It's certainly a lot nosier driving piles than it is to drill," he said. "I would say the vibration that would be caused by pile driving would have also been worse than that drilling."

The engineer said project managers have tried to notify residents before work begins, hanging notices on door knobs and maintaining a work schedule on a special Web site.

Though the construction contract for the bluff stabilization project does not end until January, Ruelas said he thinks workers are likely to finish sometime in November.

-- Contact staff writer Paul Sisson at (760) 901-4087 or
psisson@nctimes.com



Copyright 1999-2007, California Coastal Coalition
Phone: (760) 944-3564